Folks, this type of thing never happens. Oh, who are we kidding—it happens all the time. (See: Greyson Chance, Lin Yu Chun, etc.) Ten-year-old Pittsburgh native Jackie Evancho was chosen by America’s Got Talent viewers to compete in last night’s YouTube acts round. And not only did Jackie—who, as host Nick Cannon said, has a timeless voice—sing well, she blew the judges away and her competition out of the water. This of course led us to dig up Evancho’s cover of Britney Spears’ “Everytime,” from her debut album Prelude To A Dream (it’s on iTunes)

And, yes—six years later, we still find it confounding to write this song’s title as one word